In late 2020, TikTok creators went viral with “I’m not ugly, just poor” videos poking fun at how financial status, grooming, skincare and styling dictated perceived attractiveness.
“It was a hilarious – and painful – moment in the history of social media where all at once many people joked about how we were all being priced out of today’s beauty ideal,” Dr. Jordan Foster told host Rea Pallay on a recent episode of the Office of Research Services’ Research Recast(ed) podcast.
Young people’s thoughts on wealth and their personal finances are just one aspect of the sociology professor’s research, which explores, among other things, what beauty means today and how beauty ideals are shaped by celebrity images, social media and heavily augmented figures and faces.
“Young people face what we would say is a contradictory and challenging set of injunctions or appeals,” says Dr. Foster. “Look good, feel awesome. Don’t tell anyone you’ve done the work. Keep up with the appearance pressures, but never confess to the fact that those treatments feel intensive or that they might be punishing. And on top of that, many feel completely priced out of today’s beauty ideal.”
If the ideal is to look like the Kardashians or Kylie Jenner, says Dr. Foster, that requires expensive treatments that most people – certainly not students – can afford, whether it’s a skincare routine that involves an $80 vitamin C serum, a $400- to $800-dollar lip injection or multiple units of Botox at $6 to $11 each.
That was the inspiration for Dr. Foster’s research project, “Navigating the Beauty Bind,” which used focus groups to ask young people what it means to be beautiful today. The result was a conceptual tool that can be used to understand the predicament many of his research participants find themselves in: being expected to work on their appearance while revealing investments that make them seem silly or superficial.
Many of the same tensions and contradictions that Foster observed around appearance also emerge in conversations about money, success and the pursuit of “the good life.”
Go to YouTube
Currently, Dr. Foster is working on “Seeing Wealth,” a project that explores students’ exposure to affluence on social media and how that exposure shapes their aspirations, ambitions and financial behaviours.
“Across our focus group interviewees at MacEwan and the University of Toronto, there is a broad awareness of the fact that not everything we see on social media is real – it often highlights only the best parts – and that’s true also for displays of wealth. Some of it has to be fake.”
Knowing the person they see on social media probably can’t actually afford that Gucci bag or the trip to the Maldives they posted on Instagram, however, doesn’t seem to change the fact that this evidence of wealth and success seems to be driving up the pressure to perform really well, to get an awesome job, to make six figures right out of your undergraduate education.
“Social media will probably always be enchanting, in part because we’re invited to look at aspirational content – things that might be true for ourselves or for others,” says Dr. Foster.
But as social media evolves and AI continues to make its way into our lives, he says, questions about how difficult it is to tell what’s natural, edited or enhanced – when it comes to our appearance and our finances – are only becoming more important.
“I have concerns. And as new concerns arise, as AI becomes more adept and as institutions fail to regulate its spread, we all need to keep these things in mind.”